We absolutely loved this place, the atmosphere was great.. we loved the bar area. The ambiance is amazing.. totally recommend sitting down by bar if there is available seating and you have 4 or less in your group. Definitely coming back to try other menu items..

The food we had was awesome! Tons of flavor! Tasted homemade. The sauce and Italian sausage was homemade. Unlimited salad and bread sticks with our meal were very tasty! I highly recommend this place for authentic Italian food!

The layout and decor are just fabulous. Very Rat Pack with lots of Dino. There needs to be more soft services to help absorb sound though. People can't hear each other, so they talk louder, increasing the volume, forcing others to talk louder to be heard, and round it goes again until the entire dining room is just shouting at each other. Is it a deal killer? No. Just really uncomfortable for those of us with excellent hearing. The service was impeccable. Never needed to ask for dishes to be cleared, water to be refilled, or the need for boxes for left-overs - and there were a lot. Very friendly but not fake trolling for increased tips. Though if she WAS faking, you'd never know, so it wouldn't matter anyway. She was great. The food is delicious. I AM disappointed they don't make fresh pasta, however what they do with boxed pasta is wonderful. Unlike an East Side Italian eatery, they do NOT price gouge as if they are putting in the time and attention to make it fresh. The prices are appropriate for the portion size received. We both took home enough left-overs for two more full meals. So lunch yesterday and today made everyone else in the office suite jealous. We started with the Arancini and Mozzarella Marinara, Mom had the Sicilian Pork Tenderloin, and I had the Chicken al Pietro. You start with the family style salad and breadsticks. Speaking of breadsticks, what is the purpose of serving 3 breadsticks to 2 people? Serve 2 or serve 4. Three is idiotic. Although the Arancini was creamy, it was NOT filled with any short rib meat. There was barely a drop of a reddish colored sauce in the middle. This WAS over-priced. To spend 10 on two golf ball sized fried rice balls instead of the menu description is QUITE a let down. The mozzarella marinara was served in an interesting format. Not sticks, not nuggets, but as (the best description I can say is) "planks." I really liked it that way. It took out the finger food aspect of the appetizer. Mom let me try her pork and the seasoning was aMAZing. So delicious. The chicken I had was also VERY good. I'm not usually a fan of sundried tomatoes but I figured I could pick them out if I didn't like them in there. They are just the right amount of sweet to balance the bitter in the wine sauce. Even though the arancini was a huge disappointment, I'm going to still give food five stars as everything TASTED excellent.

It was my first time to come to this restaurant and let me tell you, this was so delicious Italian food salad and breadsticks ... . I was crazy to find an Italian restaurant and with real Italian food I give it a 10. Coming again soon. Thank you

Today was my 24th Birthday and I was unsure where to go so last week I put in a reservation for my family & my girlfriend, PHENOMENAL! I absolutely loved the team & how fast we were seated, we got our food & our waitress was amazing, got our appetizer before our main food so we had enough time to get through & the food was amazing. I got the Parmigiana & Lasagna as a duo together with Spinach Artichoke, my sister had the Chicken Alfredo, my father had the Monster Italian Sub, my mother had a huge Lasagna & my girlfriend had Cheese Ravioli & everyone was so happy & I did not regret coming here to show them this amazing place, I absolutely love their salad because I hate salad normally but this place? I can devour more than I ever had in my 24 years of living so I'm really happy this place is here because this was an amazing experience. Thank you to everyone that made tonight great for me, I love the Spinach Artichoke tho

A great Italian restaurant, been in Milwaukee, area for years. Took family for lunch after Christmas. Food was some of the best Italian you will eat. Ergie our waiter, was great; friendly, courteous, and attentive. Ate there, when in town last Christmas, and was back this year. Ate there many times over the years, and was never disappointed.

Busy on a Sunday but service is good. Dressing on salad is so yummy & fried calamari was a huge portion! We ordered short rib bolognese & their prime rib special.

I had an exceptional experience at That's Amore Italian Restaurant. The staff were friendly and attentive, ensuring all my requests were promptly addressed. The dining area was impeccably clean, creating a pleasant atmosphere. Most importantly, the food was delicious, leaving me eager to return and explore more of their Italian entrees. I highly recommend this restaurant! God bless all of you at That's Amore!